Sorted common to legendary. Each card says when it feeds, where it holds, and what to tie on.
Blue Tang
★☆☆☆☆ Common · steady
Day, the reef, the shallows. Try Shrimp, on Oak Caster · 6 lb Mono.
Day (9–17)0.2–1.5 lbtrophy 1 lb●○○○○
Sergeant Major
★☆☆☆☆ Common · steady
Day, the reef, the shallows. Try Shrimp or Squid Strip, on Oak Caster · 6 lb Mono.
Day (9–17)0.1–0.6 lbtrophy 0.4 lb●○○○○
Queen Triggerfish
★★☆☆☆ Uncommon · runs
Day, the reef. Try Green Crab or Squid Strip, on Glass Rod · 12 lb Mono.
Day (9–17)1–10 lbtrophy 6 lb●●○○○
Stoplight Parrotfish
★★☆☆☆ Uncommon · steady
Day, the reef. Try Green Crab or Shrimp, on Glass Rod · 12 lb Mono.
Day (9–17)1–8 lbtrophy 5 lb●●○○○
Yellowtail Snapper
★★☆☆☆ Uncommon · runs
Dusk, the reef. Try Shrimp or Squid Strip, on Glass Rod · 6 lb Mono.
Dusk (17–21)0.5–5 lbtrophy 3.5 lb●●○○○
Bar Jack
★★★☆☆ Rare · runs hard
Day, the reef, the current. Try the Jig Head or Minnow, on Surf Rod · 20 lb Braid.
Day (9–17)1–10 lbtrophy 6 lb●●●○○
Great Barracuda
★★★☆☆ Rare · runs hard
Day, the reef, the edge. Try the Big Spoon or Minnow, on Deep Rig · 130 lb Big Game.
Day (9–17)5–50 lbtrophy 32 lb●●●●○
Nassau Grouper
★★★☆☆ Rare · runs
Dusk, the reef, the holes. Try Squid Strip or Green Crab or Minnow, on Deep Rig · 50 lb Braid.
Dusk (17–21)3–35 lbtrophy 22 lb●●●●○
Goliath Grouper
★★★★☆ Very rare · steady
Night, the wreck. Try Cut Bait or Live Eel, on Deep Rig · 130 lb Big Game.
Night (21–5)40–400 lbtrophy 250 lb●●●●●
Mutton Snapper
★★★★☆ Very rare · runs hard
Dusk, the reef, the holes. Try Shrimp or Green Crab or Squid Strip, on Deep Rig · 130 lb Big Game.
Dusk (17–21)4–30 lbtrophy 20 lb●●●●○
Permit
★★★★☆ Very rare · runs hard
Day, the flats. Try Green Crab or Shrimp, on Deep Rig · 130 lb Big Game.
Day (9–17)5–45 lbtrophy 30 lb●●●●○
Sawfish
★★★★★ Legendary · runs
Night, the flats, deep water. Try Cut Bait or Green Crab, on Deep Rig · 130 lb Big Game.
Night (21–5)50–500 lbtrophy 320 lb●●●●●
The ones that won't come easy
Goliath Grouper — night (21–5), the wreck. Bring Cut Bait or Live Eel, on the Deep Rig · 130 lb Big Game. It steady. Trophy at 250 lb.
Mutton Snapper — dusk (17–21), the reef, the holes. Bring Shrimp or Green Crab or Squid Strip, on the Deep Rig · 130 lb Big Game. It runs hard — let it, every time. Trophy at 20 lb.
Permit — day (9–17), the flats. Bring Green Crab or Shrimp, on the Deep Rig · 130 lb Big Game. It runs hard — let it, every time. Trophy at 30 lb.
Sawfish — night (21–5), the flats, deep water. Bring Cut Bait or Green Crab, on the Deep Rig · 130 lb Big Game. It runs. Trophy at 320 lb.
Junk you'll pull up
Old Boot, Tangled Line, Lost Crab Pot, Someone Else's Lure, Kelp Tangle. Worth a coin or two, and a good story.